ClutchCalcs

Hosting & Rentals

Short-Term vs Long-Term Rental Comparison

STR (short-term rental) grosses 2-3x more but has higher costs, taxes, and management burden. LTR is steady, easier, lower revenue.

STR annual advantage

STR annual net
LTR annual net
STR % advantage

FAQ

When does STR clearly win? +
Tourist destinations (beach, ski, theme park), 70%+ occupancy, premium rates. Easy 2-3x LTR income.
When LTR wins? +
Outer suburbs, low-tourism markets, properties under 1 bedroom. Plus when you value your time — LTR is 5-10 hrs/year vs 100-300 hrs/year for STR.